detail,mark,matthew,luke,john,extra_gospel_attestation,ot_citation_by_gospel,single_source
Born in Bethlehem,no,yes,yes,no,None (John 7:42 crowd only expects it),Matt cites Mic 5:2,no
Virgin birth,no,yes,yes,no,None,Matt cites Isa 7:14,no
Flight to Egypt,no,yes,no,no,None,Matt cites Hos 11:1,yes
Star and Magi,no,yes,no,no,None,None explicit,yes
Slaughter of innocents,no,yes,no,no,NO INDEPENDENT RECORD despite Herod cruelties being extensively documented,Matt cites Jer 31:15,yes
Called Nazarene,no,yes,implied,yes,Residence attested,Matt cites unclear source,no
John Baptist as forerunner,yes,yes,yes,yes,Josephus Ant. 18.5.2,Multiple cite Isa 40:3 / Mal 3:1,no
Ministry in Galilee,yes,yes,yes,yes,Tacitus region implicit,Matt cites Isa 9,no
Donkey entry,yes,yes,yes,yes,None,Matt and John cite Zech 9:9,no
Last Supper institution,yes,yes,yes,different_form,1 Cor 11:23-26 (early),Luke cites Jer 31:31 implicitly,no
Silence before accusers,yes,yes,implicit,no,None,None explicit,no
Crucifixion under Pilate,yes,yes,yes,yes,Tacitus; Josephus; Talmud,Multiple cite Psa 22,no
Division of garments / casting lots,yes,yes,yes,yes,None,John cites Psa 22:18,no
Thirty pieces of silver,no,yes,no,no,None,Matt cites Zech 11:12-13 (misattributes to Jeremiah),yes
Potter's field,no,yes,no,no,None,Matt cites Zech 11:13,yes
Judas's death,no,hanging,Acts different version,no,CONFLICTING ACCOUNTS between Matthew and Acts,None,yes
Joseph of Arimathea burial,yes,yes,yes,yes,None,Isa 53:9 NEVER cited by evangelists,no
Side pierced with spear,no,no,no,yes,None,John cites Zech 12:10,yes
Bones not broken,no,no,no,yes,None,John cites Exo 12:46 / Psa 34:20,yes
Empty tomb,yes,yes,yes,yes,1 Cor 15:4 (early creed),None explicit,no
Resurrection appearances,long_ending,yes,yes,yes,1 Cor 15:5-8 (early creed),None explicit,no