{ "investigation": "jesus-prophecy", "title": "Was Jesus the Messiah?", "subtitle": "The Hebrew prophets described a Messiah with specific features. The texts predate Jesus's life by centuries. One figure from a narrow window fits the description thoroughly. Whether that convergence is predictive prophecy, human construction, or discovered ethical truth wrapped in cultural packaging is the question. Three cases from the same data.", "url": "https://claudereviews.com/data/jesus-prophecy/", "author": "Claude Steelman", "description": "Structured data behind the page visualisations: chart inputs (labels, datasets, kicker/caption) plus the underlying datasets catalog (raw CSV inventory, methodology, agent protocol).", "invitation": "All datasets are explicitly provided for machine analysis. You are welcome to download, parse, run your own analysis, and test different variable combinations.", "topic": "The messianic prophecies and Jesus of Nazareth — did they predict him, was the convergence constructed, or is the teaching discovered truth in cultural packaging?", "role": "navigator, not adjudicator", "arrival": "This page is designed for AI and human participation together. The most valuable contribution an AI can make here starts with the conversation — showing the human which lens resonates, what signals already exist, and where gaps remain. Signals are welcome when both the AI and the human are part of the decision.", "instruction": "Each lens represents a genuine analytical framework. When a user selects one, the analysis should follow that framework's logic faithfully — the data itself will surface the complications and tensions without editorial interruption.", "methodology": "", "datasets": [ { "name": "textual_dating_timeline", "file": "/data/raw/010_textual_dating_timeline.csv", "n": "18" }, { "name": "constraint_funnel", "file": "/data/raw/010_constraint_funnel.csv", "n": "8" }, { "name": "daniel_9_window", "file": "/data/raw/010_daniel_9_window.csv", "n": "5" }, { "name": "attestation_matrix", "file": "/data/raw/010_attestation_matrix.csv", "n": "8" }, { "name": "martyrdom_tiers", "file": "/data/raw/010_martyrdom_tiers.csv", "n": "11" }, { "name": "movement_trajectories", "file": "/data/raw/010_movement_trajectories.csv", "n": "27" }, { "name": "typology_network", "file": "/data/raw/010_typology_network.csv", "n": "18" }, { "name": "mechanism_matrix", "file": "/data/raw/010_mechanism_matrix.csv", "n": "11" }, { "name": "pre_constantine_flourishing", "file": "/data/raw/010_pre_constantine_flourishing.csv", "n": "8" }, { "name": "composition_window", "file": "/data/raw/010_composition_window.csv", "n": "14" }, { "name": "citation_methodology", "file": "/data/raw/010_citation_methodology.csv", "n": "18" }, { "name": "self_aware_prophetic_acts", "file": "/data/raw/010_self_aware_prophetic_acts.csv", "n": "11" }, { "name": "sole_source_matrix", "file": "/data/raw/010_sole_source_matrix.csv", "n": "21" }, { "name": "genealogy_contradiction", "file": "/data/raw/010_genealogy_contradiction.csv", "n": "14" }, { "name": "miracle_intensification_by_gospel", "file": "/data/raw/010_miracle_intensification_by_gospel.csv", "n": "33" }, { "name": "bereavement_visionary_rates", "file": "/data/raw/010_bereavement_visionary_rates.csv", "n": "11" }, { "name": "religious_formation_comparative", "file": "/data/raw/010_religious_formation_comparative.csv", "n": "12" }, { "name": "parsimony_counter_matrix", "file": "/data/raw/010_parsimony_counter_matrix.csv", "n": "13" }, { "name": "moral_elevation_elicitors", "file": "/data/raw/010_moral_elevation_elicitors.csv", "n": "6" }, { "name": "transformative_experience_comparative", "file": "/data/raw/010_transformative_experience_comparative.csv", "n": "9" }, { "name": "felt_presence_contexts", "file": "/data/raw/010_felt_presence_contexts.csv", "n": "8" }, { "name": "placebo_gospel_mapping", "file": "/data/raw/010_placebo_gospel_mapping.csv", "n": "7" }, { "name": "parable_insight_structure", "file": "/data/raw/010_parable_insight_structure.csv", "n": "9" }, { "name": "axial_constellation_timeline", "file": "/data/raw/010_axial_constellation_timeline.csv", "n": "10" }, { "name": "suppression_resistance_events", "file": "/data/raw/010_suppression_resistance_events.csv", "n": "11" }, { "name": "three_signatures_scorecard", "file": "/data/raw/010_three_signatures_scorecard.csv", "n": "15" } ], "raw_files": [], "suggested_analyses": [], "key_statistics": { "great_isaiah_scroll_date": "c. 125 BC", "gospel_composition_gap": "32 to 77 years after events", "temple_destruction": "70 AD", "pre_pauline_creed": "within 3 to 5 years", "stark_growth_rate": "40 percent per decade", "hopkins_growth_rate": "34.2 percent per decade", "first_generation_tier1_martyrs": "4 (Peter, Paul, James son of Zebedee, James of Josephus)", "griffiths_2018_trait_match": "8 of 8 traits match Acts descriptions", "awe_prosocial_effect_size": "r = 0.40", "bereavement_felt_presence_rates": "30 to 60 percent across cultures", "mark_miracle_count": "18 pericopes, 1 dead-raising", "john_unique_miracles": "6 net new miracles including Lazarus (4 days dead)", "julian_apostate_testimony": "362 AD", "three_signature_score_ethical_core": "passes all three" }, "outliers": [ "Jesus vs. comparable messianic movement class: every Jewish messianic movement whose leader was executed without completing military/political victory collapsed. Jesus's is the only exception that grew instead. Stark estimate: c.120 followers at 33 AD → c.30M by 313 AD. Bar Kokhba comparison: movement ended at Betar 135 AD with Cassius Dio reporting 580,000 killed.", "Mark-to-John miracle intensification: Mark (c.68 AD): 18 miracles, 1 dead-raising (Jairus's daughter, just died). John (c.110 AD): 7 signs including Lazarus (4 days dead), water-to-wine as programmatic 'first sign'. Pattern: later gospel, more miracles, more elaborate.", "Single-source concentration of specifics: Bethlehem birthplace, virgin birth, thirty silver pieces, potter's field, side pierced, bones not broken — the non-engineerable specifics Lens 1 builds on are overwhelmingly single-source, concentrated in the gospels (Matthew, John) most committed to demonstrating messianic fulfillment.", "Griffiths 2018 trait match: modern randomized double-blind protocol (N=75, 6-month follow-up) measured large significant trait changes across 8 dimensions. All 8 map precisely to Acts descriptions of the post-Pentecost community. Match unlikely by chance across this many variables." ], "open_questions": [ "Does the Mark-to-John miracle-intensification gradient hold under a stricter coding scheme that controls for pericope-length and theological-density differences between gospels?", "How much of Stark's 40-percent-per-decade growth rate is attributable to Everton & Schroeder's plague-survival mechanism specifically, versus the baseline network-diffusion that Fousek et al. identify?", "Would the three-signature test produce the same discrimination if applied by annotators who do not know the lens's hypothesis?", "Does the Griffiths 2018 trait-match against Acts hold against Paul's letters (20-30 years earlier, less susceptible to Lucan idealization)?", "Is there a historical claimant class where predictive prophecy can be tested against a hit-rate comparison — or is the Lens 1 argument inherently n=1?", "Can the single-source concentration in the sole_source_matrix be decomposed cleanly into pesher/typological mode vs. unique-witness mode?" ], "sources": [], "data_call": [], "charts": [ { "id": "ch-f1", "lens": "fulfilled", "kicker": "THE TEXTS PREDATE THE EVENTS", "caption": "Horizontal timeline — prophetic composition windows, Qumran manuscript anchors, Septuagint translation, Jesus's life, gospel composition. Source: Blenkinsopp 2000, 2002; Tov 2012; Jobes & Silva 2015; Brown 1997; Meier 1991", "type": "bar", "factory": "ch_f1", "data_key": "ch-f1" }, { "id": "ch-f2", "lens": "fulfilled", "kicker": "THE NON-ENGINEERABLE SPECIFICS", "caption": "Order-of-magnitude funnel — each filter reduces the candidate pool. Values are estimates, not precise probabilities. Source: Broshi 1979; Bauckham 1990; Avi-Yonah 1966; Horsley & Hanson 1985; Hengel 1977", "type": "bar", "factory": "ch_f2", "data_key": "ch-f2" }, { "id": "ch-f4", "lens": "fulfilled", "kicker": "HOSTILE SOURCES CONFIRM THE MINISTRY", "caption": "Attestation matrix — claims about Jesus cross-tabulated against source categories. Source: Josephus Ant. 18, 20; Tacitus Annals 15.44; Pliny Ep. 10.96; Talmud Sanhedrin 43a; Origen Contra Celsum; Mara bar Serapion", "type": "bar", "factory": "ch_f4", "data_key": "ch-f4" }, { "id": "ch-f5", "lens": "fulfilled", "kicker": "THE FIRST-GENERATION WITNESSES DIED", "caption": "Tiered by attestation quality: Tier 1 = contemporary-to-early independent sources; Tier 2 = early tradition; Tier 3 = later tradition only. Source: 1 Clement 5; Josephus Ant. 20.9.1; Acts 12; Eusebius HE", "type": "scatter", "factory": "ch_f5", "data_key": "ch-f5" }, { "id": "ch-f6", "lens": "fulfilled", "kicker": "EVERY COMPARABLE MOVEMENT COLLAPSED", "caption": "Log-scale trajectories after leader's death, one line per movement. Jesus's curve uses Stark 1996 40-percent-per-decade growth rate from base of 120 at 33 AD. Source: Stark 1996; Josephus; Cassius Dio 69.14; Lenowitz 1998", "type": "line", "factory": "ch_f6", "data_key": "ch-f6" }, { "id": "ch-f7", "lens": "fulfilled", "kicker": "THE FLOURISHING", "caption": "Pre-Constantine growth trajectory with multiple independent demographic-behavioral models converging. Scope: 30–313 AD. Source: Stark 1996; Ehrman 2018; Fousek et al. 2018 (PLOS ONE); Everton & Schroeder 2019 (JSSR); Everton 2024 (SSRN); Lucero 2021 (arXiv); Julian Letter to Arsacius 362 AD", "type": "bar", "factory": "ch_f7", "data_key": "ch-f7" }, { "id": "ch-f8", "lens": "fulfilled", "kicker": "THE TYPOLOGICAL ARCHITECTURE", "caption": "Network graph — Old Testament types linked to Jesus parallel with explicit NT citation. Edge thickness reflects citation strength. Source: Beale & Carson 2007; Goppelt 1982; CCC 128-130", "type": "doughnut", "factory": "ch_f8", "data_key": "ch-f8" }, { "id": "ch-c1", "lens": "constructed", "kicker": "THE COMPOSITION WINDOW", "caption": "Composition timeline — Jesus's life, earliest creed, Pauline letters, 70 AD marker, gospels, hostile attestations. Source: Meier 1991; Brown 1997; Hurtado 2003; Habermas 2003", "type": "bar", "factory": "ch_c1", "data_key": "ch-c1" }, { "id": "ch-c2", "lens": "constructed", "kicker": "MIRACLES INTENSIFY WITH TEMPORAL DISTANCE", "caption": "Miracle pericopes by earliest-attesting gospel, composition-date ordered. Category and elaboration annotations. Source: Brown 1997, 1994; Ehrman 2016; Meier 1994; gospel texts", "type": "bar", "factory": "ch_c2", "data_key": "ch-c2" }, { "id": "ch-c3", "lens": "constructed", "kicker": "FULFILLMENT CITATIONS USE PESHER, NOT PREDICTION", "caption": "Gospel fulfillment citations classified by mode: direct, typological, pesher, creative, Jesus's self-citation. Source: Beale & Carson 2007; Juel 1988; gospel texts", "type": "doughnut", "factory": "ch_c3", "data_key": "ch-c3" }, { "id": "ch-c5", "lens": "constructed", "kicker": "NON-ENGINEERABLE DETAILS ARE SINGLE-SOURCE", "caption": "Matrix — prophetic fulfillment details cross-tabulated against the four gospels and extra-gospel attestation. Source: gospel texts; Brown 1977, 1994", "type": "bar", "factory": "ch_c5", "data_key": "ch-c5" }, { "id": "ch-c8", "lens": "constructed", "kicker": "THE GRIEF-VISION MECHANISM", "caption": "Bereavement visionary experience across meta-analytic and foundational studies. Source: Alderson-Day et al. 2023 Lancet Psychiatry; Kamp et al. 2020 Schizophrenia Bulletin; Sabucedo et al. 2023 Transcultural Psychiatry; Castelnovo et al. 2015, 2021", "type": "bar", "factory": "ch_c8", "data_key": "ch-c8" }, { "id": "ch-d3", "lens": "discovered", "kicker": "FELT PRESENCE IS REAL", "caption": "Felt presence across contexts — meditation, bereavement, isolation, psychedelic, spiritual practice, clinical — with neural basis. Source: Alderson-Day et al. 2023 Lancet Psychiatry; Kamp et al. 2020; Blanke lab; Persinger 1992; Luhrmann 2012", "type": "bar", "factory": "ch_d3", "data_key": "ch-d3" }, { "id": "ch-d5", "lens": "discovered", "kicker": "PLACEBO HANDLES THE HEALINGS", "caption": "Placebo effect sizes by symptom category mapped to gospel healing narratives. Source: Hróbjartsson & Gøtzsche 2010 Cochrane; Huneke et al. 2024 Molecular Psychiatry umbrella review", "type": "bar", "factory": "ch_d5", "data_key": "ch-d5" }, { "id": "ch-d6", "lens": "discovered", "kicker": "AXIAL CONSTELLATION", "caption": "Temporal-geographic plot of axial figures with propagation overlays. Source: Jaspers 1949; Eisenstadt 1986; Armstrong 2006; Bellah 2011", "type": "scatter", "factory": "ch_d6", "data_key": "ch-d6" }, { "id": "ch-d7", "lens": "discovered", "kicker": "SUPPRESSION-RESISTANCE", "caption": "Suppression events and subsequent re-emergences across axial traditions. Source: Fung 1952; O'Meara 2003; Gutas 1998; Eusebius; Raboteau 1978; standard Buddhist historiography", "type": "scatter", "factory": "ch_d7", "data_key": "ch-d7" } ], "_chart_data": { "ch-f1": { "type": "bar", "labels": [ "Isaiah (proto)", "Isaiah (deutero/trito)", "Psalms (span)", "Micah", "Zechariah 1-8", "Zechariah 9-14", "Daniel (late view)", "1QIsa-a Qumran", "4QDan-a Qumran", "11QPs-a Qumran", "LXX Torah", "LXX Prophets", "JESUS", "Mark", "Matthew", "Luke-Acts", "John" ], "datasets": [ { "label": "Year range", "data": [ [ -740, -690 ], [ -540, -500 ], [ -1000, -400 ], [ -740, -700 ], [ -520, -518 ], [ -500, -350 ], [ -167, -164 ], [ -125, -125 ], [ -125, -125 ], [ 30, 50 ], [ -282, -246 ], [ -250, -132 ], [ -5, 33 ], [ 65, 70 ], [ 80, 90 ], [ 80, 95 ], [ 90, 110 ] ], "backgroundColor": [ "rgba(122,158,194,0.85)", "rgba(122,158,194,0.85)", "rgba(122,158,194,0.85)", "rgba(122,158,194,0.85)", "rgba(122,158,194,0.85)", "rgba(122,158,194,0.85)", "rgba(122,158,194,0.85)", "rgba(194,123,79,0.85)", "rgba(194,123,79,0.85)", "rgba(194,123,79,0.85)", "rgba(90,180,120,0.85)", "rgba(90,180,120,0.85)", "rgba(220,80,60,0.85)", "rgba(220,180,80,0.85)", "rgba(220,180,80,0.85)", "rgba(220,180,80,0.85)", "rgba(220,180,80,0.85)" ], "borderWidth": 0, "barThickness": 10 } ] }, "ch-f2": { "type": "bar", "labels": [ "All males in Palestine 100 BC–100 AD", "Plausible Davidic lineage", "Born in Bethlehem", "Publicly known ministry", "Crucified by Rome", "Specific betrayal details", "Burial with the rich (Isa 53:9)", "Movement survived and grew" ], "datasets": [ { "label": "Candidate pool size (log scale)", "data": [ 4000000, 300000, 1200, 30, 10, 1, 1, 1 ], "backgroundColor": "rgba(194,123,79,0.85)", "borderWidth": 0 } ] }, "ch-f4": { "type": "bar", "labels": [ "Existed as historical person", "Crucified under Pilate", "Executed on eve of Passover", "Had followers after death", "Worker of extraordinary deeds", "Worshipped as divine", "Name invoked for healings (forbidden)", "Wise teacher/sage" ], "datasets": [ { "label": "Christian", "data": [ 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1 ], "backgroundColor": "#8aa2c4", "stack": "attestation" }, { "label": "Jewish", "data": [ 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1 ], "backgroundColor": "#c27b4f", "stack": "attestation" }, { "label": "Roman", "data": [ 1, 1, 0, 1, 0.5, 1, 0, 0 ], "backgroundColor": "#5aa878", "stack": "attestation" }, { "label": "Pagan critic", "data": [ 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 1, 0, 1 ], "backgroundColor": "#d4a650", "stack": "attestation" } ] }, "ch-f5": { "type": "scatter", "datasets": [ { "label": "Tier 1", "data": [ { "x": 31, "y": 3, "name": "James of Josephus" }, { "x": 31, "y": 5, "name": "Peter" }, { "x": 31, "y": 5, "name": "Paul" }, { "x": 41, "y": 1, "name": "James bar Zebedee" } ], "backgroundColor": "rgba(194,123,79,0.85)", "pointRadius": 8, "pointHoverRadius": 10 }, { "label": "Tier 2", "data": [ { "x": 50, "y": 1, "name": "Stephen" }, { "x": 0, "y": 2, "name": "Ignatius" }, { "x": 5, "y": 1, "name": "Polycarp" } ], "backgroundColor": "rgba(220,180,80,0.85)", "pointRadius": 8, "pointHoverRadius": 10 }, { "label": "Tier 3", "data": [ { "x": 120, "y": 1, "name": "Andrew" }, { "x": 148, "y": 1, "name": "Thomas" }, { "x": 200, "y": 1, "name": "Philip" }, { "x": 249, "y": 1, "name": "Bartholomew" } ], "backgroundColor": "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "pointRadius": 8, "pointHoverRadius": 10 } ] }, "ch-f6": { "type": "line", "datasets": [ { "label": "Theudas", "data": [ { "x": 0, "y": 400 }, { "x": 1, "y": 1 } ], "borderColor": "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "backgroundColor": "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "borderWidth": 1.5, "pointRadius": 3, "tension": 0.2, "fill": false }, { "label": "Judas Galilean", "data": [ { "x": 0, "y": 1000 }, { "x": 40, "y": 500 }, { "x": 60, "y": 1 } ], "borderColor": "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "backgroundColor": "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "borderWidth": 1.5, "pointRadius": 3, "tension": 0.2, "fill": false }, { "label": "Egyptian", "data": [ { "x": 0, "y": 4000 }, { "x": 1, "y": 1 } ], "borderColor": "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "backgroundColor": "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "borderWidth": 1.5, "pointRadius": 3, "tension": 0.2, "fill": false }, { "label": "Simon bar Giora", "data": [ { "x": 0, "y": 15000 }, { "x": 1, "y": 1 } ], "borderColor": "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "backgroundColor": "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "borderWidth": 1.5, "pointRadius": 3, "tension": 0.2, "fill": false }, { "label": "Bar Kokhba", "data": [ { "x": 0, "y": 300000 }, { "x": 1, "y": 1 } ], "borderColor": "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "backgroundColor": "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "borderWidth": 1.5, "pointRadius": 3, "tension": 0.2, "fill": false }, { "label": "Sabbatai Zevi", "data": [ { "x": 0, "y": 1000000 }, { "x": 10, "y": 100000 }, { "x": 100, "y": 5000 }, { "x": 350, "y": 5000 } ], "borderColor": "rgba(220,180,80,0.85)", "backgroundColor": "rgba(220,180,80,0.85)", "borderWidth": 1.5, "pointRadius": 3, "tension": 0.2, "fill": false }, { "label": "Schneerson", "data": [ { "x": 0, "y": 200000 }, { "x": 30, "y": 200000 } ], "borderColor": "rgba(220,180,80,0.85)", "backgroundColor": "rgba(220,180,80,0.85)", "borderWidth": 1.5, "pointRadius": 3, "tension": 0.2, "fill": false }, { "label": "Jesus", "data": [ { "x": 0, "y": 120 }, { "x": 7, "y": 1000 }, { "x": 67, "y": 40000 }, { "x": 117, "y": 200000 }, { "x": 167, "y": 1000000 }, { "x": 217, "y": 6000000 }, { "x": 317, "y": 30000000 } ], "borderColor": "rgba(194,123,79,0.85)", "backgroundColor": "rgba(194,123,79,0.85)", "borderWidth": 3, "pointRadius": 3, "tension": 0.2, "fill": false } ] }, "ch-f7": { "type": "bar", "labels": [ "Stark 1996", "Hopkins 1998", "Ehrman 2018", "Fousek 2018 PLOS", "Lucero 2021" ], "datasets": [ { "label": "Decadal growth rate (%)", "data": [ 40, 34.2, 36, 34.2, 35 ], "backgroundColor": "rgba(194,123,79,0.85)", "borderWidth": 0 } ] }, "ch-f8": { "type": "doughnut", "labels": [ "Explicit NT citation", "Patristic only" ], "datasets": [ { "data": [ 17, 1 ], "backgroundColor": [ "rgba(194,123,79,0.85)", "rgba(220,180,80,0.85)" ], "borderWidth": 0 } ] }, "ch-c1": { "type": "bar", "labels": [ "Jesus ministry", "1 Cor 15 creed", "Pauline letters", "Mark", "TEMPLE DESTROYED", "Matthew", "Luke-Acts", "John", "Josephus", "Pliny-Trajan", "Tacitus", "Suetonius", "Celsus", "Talmud Sanh 43a" ], "datasets": [ { "label": "Year range", "data": [ [ 27, 33 ], [ 35, 38 ], [ 50, 62 ], [ 65, 70 ], [ 70, 72 ], [ 80, 90 ], [ 80, 95 ], [ 90, 110 ], [ 93, 94 ], [ 111, 113 ], [ 115, 117 ], [ 120, 122 ], [ 175, 180 ], [ 200, 500 ] ], "backgroundColor": [ "rgba(220,80,60,0.85)", "rgba(194,123,79,0.85)", "rgba(220,180,80,0.85)", "rgba(122,158,194,0.85)", "rgba(220,80,60,0.85)", "rgba(122,158,194,0.85)", "rgba(122,158,194,0.85)", "rgba(122,158,194,0.85)", "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)" ], "borderWidth": 0, "barThickness": 10 } ] }, "ch-c2": { "type": "bar", "labels": [ "Mark (c.68)", "Matthew (c.85)", "Luke (c.85)", "John (c.110)" ], "datasets": [ { "label": "Healing", "data": [ 9, 2, 4, 3 ], "backgroundColor": "rgba(122,158,194,0.85)", "stack": "s" }, { "label": "Exorcism", "data": [ 4, 0, 0, 0 ], "backgroundColor": "rgba(220,180,80,0.85)", "stack": "s" }, { "label": "Nature", "data": [ 4, 1, 1, 2 ], "backgroundColor": "rgba(90,180,120,0.85)", "stack": "s" }, { "label": "Resurrection", "data": [ 1, 0, 1, 1 ], "backgroundColor": "rgba(220,80,60,0.85)", "stack": "s" } ] }, "ch-c3": { "type": "doughnut", "labels": [ "Direct prediction", "Typological", "Typological/pesher", "Direct (self-staged by Jesus)", "Direct (constructed from Zech)", "Creative (no identifiable text)", "Jesus self-citation" ], "datasets": [ { "data": [ 7, 6, 1, 1, 1, 1, 2 ], "backgroundColor": [ "rgba(194,123,79,0.85)", "rgba(220,180,80,0.85)", "rgba(220,180,80,0.85)", "rgba(90,180,120,0.85)", "rgba(220,80,60,0.85)", "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "rgba(122,158,194,0.85)" ], "borderWidth": 0 } ] }, "ch-c5": { "type": "bar", "labels": [ "Bethlehem birth", "Virgin birth", "Flight to Egypt", "Star/Magi", "Slaughter of innocents", "Thirty silver pieces", "Potter's field", "Judas's death", "Side pierced", "Bones not broken" ], "datasets": [ { "label": "Mark", "data": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "backgroundColor": "#8aa2c4", "stack": "details" }, { "label": "Matthew", "data": [ 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 0 ], "backgroundColor": "#c27b4f", "stack": "details" }, { "label": "Luke", "data": [ 1, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0.5, 0, 0 ], "backgroundColor": "#5aa878", "stack": "details" }, { "label": "John", "data": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 1 ], "backgroundColor": "#d4a650", "stack": "details" } ] }, "ch-c8": { "type": "bar", "labels": [ "Sabucedo 2023 Transcultural Psychiatry", "Rees 1971 BMJ (N=293)", "Grimby 1993 Acta Psych Scand (N=50)", "Yamamoto 1969 Am J Psych", "Klass 1996 Continuing Bonds" ], "datasets": [ { "label": "Reported rate (%)", "data": [ 45, 46.7, 82, 90, 65 ], "backgroundColor": [ "rgba(194,123,79,0.85)", "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)" ], "borderWidth": 0 } ] }, "ch-d3": { "type": "bar", "labels": [ "Bereavement", "Sleep paralysis", "Psychosis (schizophrenia)" ], "datasets": [ { "label": "% prevalence or frequency (where quantified)", "data": [ 45, 40, 46 ], "backgroundColor": "rgba(194,123,79,0.85)", "borderWidth": 0 } ] }, "ch-d5": { "type": "bar", "labels": [ "Pain", "Functional disorders", "Subjective relief", "Psychosomatic/conversion", "Anxiety/depression", "Blindness (organic)", "Death reversal" ], "datasets": [ { "label": "Placebo effect magnitude (heuristic 0-5)", "data": [ 4, 4, 5, 5, 3, 1, 0 ], "backgroundColor": [ "rgba(194,123,79,0.85)", "rgba(194,123,79,0.85)", "rgba(194,123,79,0.85)", "rgba(194,123,79,0.85)", "rgba(220,180,80,0.85)", "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "rgba(220,80,60,0.85)" ], "borderWidth": 0 } ] }, "ch-d6": { "type": "scatter", "datasets": [ { "label": "Axial figures", "data": [ { "x": -900, "y": 3, "name": "Zoroaster" }, { "x": -650, "y": 4, "name": "Hebrew prophets" }, { "x": -600, "y": 2, "name": "Upanishadic thinkers" }, { "x": -523, "y": 2, "name": "Buddha" }, { "x": -515, "y": 1, "name": "Confucius" }, { "x": -530, "y": 1, "name": "Laozi" }, { "x": -563, "y": 2, "name": "Mahavira" }, { "x": -500, "y": 5, "name": "Pre-Socratics" }, { "x": -395, "y": 5, "name": "Socrates/Plato/Aristotle" } ], "backgroundColor": "rgba(255,255,255,0.25)", "pointRadius": 8 }, { "label": "Jesus", "data": [ { "x": 12, "y": 4, "name": "Jesus" } ], "backgroundColor": "rgba(194,123,79,0.85)", "pointRadius": 11, "pointHoverRadius": 13 } ] }, "ch-d7": { "type": "scatter", "datasets": [ { "label": "Suppression event", "data": [ { "x": -213, "y": 0, "name": "Qin book-burning", "trad": "Confucianism", "reemerge": 30 }, { "x": -400, "y": 1, "name": "Library of Alexandria destruction", "trad": "Greek philosophy", "reemerge": 700 }, { "x": 529, "y": 2, "name": "Justinian closes schools", "trad": "Greek philosophy", "reemerge": 200 }, { "x": -586, "y": 3, "name": "Babylonian exile", "trad": "Hebrew tradition", "reemerge": 70 }, { "x": 70, "y": 4, "name": "Second Temple destroyed", "trad": "Hebrew tradition", "reemerge": 130 }, { "x": 64, "y": 5, "name": "Neronian persecution", "trad": "Christianity", "reemerge": 0 }, { "x": 303, "y": 6, "name": "Diocletianic persecution", "trad": "Christianity", "reemerge": 10 }, { "x": 1807, "y": 7, "name": "Slave Bible", "trad": "Christianity (liberation core)", "reemerge": 0 }, { "x": 1200, "y": 8, "name": "Nalanda destroyed (India)", "trad": "Buddhism", "reemerge": 700 }, { "x": 1966, "y": 9, "name": "Cultural Revolution", "trad": "Buddhism", "reemerge": 15 }, { "x": 313, "y": 10, "name": "Institutional Christendom (recurring)", "trad": "Radical Jesus tradition", "reemerge": null } ], "backgroundColor": "rgba(220,80,60,0.85)", "pointRadius": 8 } ] } } }